Testimonials

Buying a house in Key West from Dallas was made so easy with Island Reality. Paige went above and beyond not only the buying process. She helped with getting contractors to build a bathroom upstairs. Paige and her crew helped with shipping furniture and unpacking boxes. I think it’s great she uses small businesses in key west. I highly recommend using Island Realty when buying a home in Key West

My husband and I had a superb experience with Paige during our Key West home purchase so we didn’t think twice about enlisting her help for the sale of our house a few years later. Putting it succinctly, we would have not been able to accomplish the sale of our house without Paige. She helped us every step of the way from finishing last minute renovations to transporting boxes to a storage facility to navigating City Hall and the city’s complicated code system. She is very well-connected and plugged in to the community. We cannot praise her enough! Everyone we speak to is surprised and amazed that any realtor would help us in the ways Paige did; she truly worked over and above what is expected and is still helping us with loose odds and ends even now a couple of months later. Choose Paige to represent you as either a home buyer or seller and you will not be disappointed in her dedication and service! Richard Vax, James Perry

You will not find a better or more dedicated real estate agent than Paige. My husband and I had been looking for a waterfront property in Key West for a few years but didn’t think we would be able to make it happen in our budget. Paige found us the perfect home in Key Haven! She was able to negotiate $300k off the asking price to keep us within our budget. We could not be more grateful! Im a local, and there are a lot of real estate agents we could have picked, but we are so happy we chose her! She has also been available for any real estate questions after closing. We love Paige and can’t imagine how we would have done this without her!

Paige has been a valuable resource for me whenever I have questions or need assistance related to real estate in the keys. Key West real estate is so nuanced and she is able to provide important expertise.

Paige is incredible! She knows her stuff, works hard, does what’s best for you, and is also just a kind person. A great partner on every level.

There is something so special about Key West that few innately understand, and Paige is one of those people: As someone who grew up in the Keys, she knows the island better than anyone (and this is coming from a fellow Conch!) and she's helped my hard-to-please family in immeasurable ways. Her professionalism, kindness, intelligence, and commitment to her clients makes her not just an amazing realtor, but person. Anyone would be lucky to work with her.

My mom owns property in Key West and Paige has been an invaluable source of knowledge about the market. I also utilized Paige's extensive knowledge and expertise while I was going through the home buying process myself in Connecticut. She spent a lot of time educating me on the buying process, researching the market we were looking to buy in and even would send me listings she thought we may be interested in, all just because she truly cares about her clients and their families! We can’t imagine not having her as our point person! She is a smart negotiator and gets the job done. If you are looking for amazing realtor to help you buy or sell a home in Key West, you won't regret hiring Paige Bethel!

Paige was amazing as our real estate agent. Any questions or concerns we had as first time buyers were quickly taken care of by Paige. She would quickly response to any questions we had and really sought to find us the perfect property for our first home purchase, and for that I can not thank her enough.

She is very friendly, very knowledgeable, extremely familiar with the area and has a wealth of information as to who can be contacted to do what needs doing on the property. When the seller failed to follow through with walkthrough commitments, she did a lot of work moving debris (she shouldn't have had to).